Did You Comply with the Law, Yet the SRS Denies Tax Overpayment Without an Audit?
If an undertaking submits an amendment to its tax declaration within the statutory period, the mere fact that the amendment was submitted shortly before the deadline does not constitute grounds to question the undertaking’s good faith or to deny the refund of a tax overpayment.
Precisely such a situation arose for an undertaking that made an amendment to its corporate income tax (CIT) declaration. As a result, the undertaking incurred a tax overpayment, which it sought to have refunded.
The State Revenue Service (SRS) denied the refund of the overpayment. The reason provided was that the declaration amendments had been submitted only one month before the expiry of the statutory three-year period. Furthermore, the SRS did not dispute either the existence of the overpayment or the correctness of its calculation.
This case serves as a reminder of a crucial principle: in a tax dispute, not only the correct tax calculation is important. Equally important is knowledge of one’s procedural rights and how the SRS must act if it disputes a declared overpayment.
Undertaking Submitted Declaration Amendment Within Deadline, But SRS Denied Overpayment
The law stipulates that a taxpayer is entitled to submit an amendment or clarification to a tax declaration to the SRS within three years after the payment deadline specified in the respective laws.
The taxpayer may exercise this right if:
- a tax audit (inspection) has not been initiated or conducted for the specific taxes and relevant taxation periods;
- a tax control invoice has not been issued in cases prescribed by law;
- a settlement agreement has not been concluded with the Director-General of the SRS;
- tax control has been terminated because no additional tax (duty) payments to the budget were determined as a result of the inspection.
In the year these events transpired, the legal norm differed slightly. However, in this particular case, two circumstances were significant:
- the undertaking submitted the declaration amendments within the statutory period – within three years from the tax payment deadline; and
- none of the aforementioned restrictions that would preclude claiming an overpayment refund applied.
Accordingly, the undertaking expected the incurred tax overpayment to be refunded. However, the SRS adopted a different decision.
Upon Receiving an Application for Tax Overpayment, SRS Must Refund Overpayment or Initiate an Audit Within 15 Days
The law provides that the SRS, upon receiving a taxpayer’s application, must within 15 days:
- refund or reallocate the tax overpayment; or
- initiate an audit.
If the SRS initiates an audit and the justification for the overpayment is confirmed as a result, the tax overpayment must be refunded or reallocated within 15 days after the audit.
Thus, the SRS’s action – refunding, reallocating the overpayment, or initiating an audit – must follow within 15 days of receiving the taxpayer’s application, unless statutory exceptions apply or specific tax laws stipulate a different procedure and deadlines.
In the specific case, the overpayment was not refunded by the SRS. Instead, the SRS pointed to the timing of when the undertaking had submitted the declaration amendments.
Amending the Declaration Shortly Before the Deadline Does Not, in Itself, Indicate Bad Faith
The undertaking had submitted the declaration amendments only one month before the expiry of the statutory three-year period.
In the SRS’s view, the undertaking could have submitted the declaration amendments earlier. As this was not done, the SRS perceived malicious intent and considered that it was not obliged to refund the overpayment to the undertaking.
Consequently, the undertaking had exercised its statutory right to submit declaration amendments and claim a tax overpayment refund, yet the very timing of exercising this right became grounds to question the undertaking’s good faith.
Furthermore, the SRS did not dispute either the existence of the overpayment or the correctness of its calculation.
The Senate did not support such an approach. A taxpayer’s good faith cannot be questioned merely because statutory rights were exercised shortly before the expiry of the prescribed deadline.
Taxpayer is Entitled to Utilize the Three-Year Period in Full
The Senate provided several significant findings in the case.
- If none of the aforementioned exceptional circumstances arise and the three-year deadline for submitting declaration amendments has been observed, the SRS is not entitled to restrict the taxpayer’s right to submit declaration amendments.
- The duration prior to the expiry of the statutory three-year period within which a taxpayer submits declaration amendments cannot serve as grounds to accuse the taxpayer of bad faith. The taxpayer is entitled to utilize the period prescribed by the legislator in full.
- Hypothetical assumptions about a taxpayer’s possible intentions for amending a tax declaration cannot constitute grounds for questioning the taxpayer’s good faith.
- The SRS’s action – refunding, reallocating the overpayment, or initiating an audit – must follow within 15 days of receiving the application.
- If the SRS decides to conduct an audit, the law does not explicitly specify within the framework of which audit the tax overpayment is to be verified. This falls within the competence of the SRS.
- The SRS must initiate the audit of the overpaid tax amount indicated in the taxpayer’s application within a three-year period from the payment deadline specified in the respective tax law. The audit must be initiated, not completed, within this period.
- If the audit has been initiated within the prescribed period, the SRS is entitled to make a decision regarding the tax overpayment even if three years have already passed since the payment deadline for the specific tax.
- As long as the SRS has not adopted a decision which, following an audit, determines a tax payment obligation different from that declared by the taxpayer, the basis for tax calculation is the declaration submitted by the taxpayer.
Therefore, if the SRS has not adopted a decision in the statutory manner which, following an audit, determines a calculation different from the taxpayer’s declaration, the SRS cannot use this to justify a refusal to acknowledge the taxpayer’s right to receive the declared tax overpayment.
If the SRS Denies a Tax Overpayment, the Undertaking Should Verify Not Only the Grounds for Denial
This case illustrates several practically important principles.
Firstly, the statutory period may be utilized in full. Submitting a declaration amendment shortly before the expiry of the three-year period does not, in itself, constitute grounds to question the taxpayer’s good faith.
Secondly, the SRS cannot substitute an audit with assumptions about the undertaking’s intentions. If a declared tax overpayment is disputed, the SRS must act in the manner prescribed by law.
Thirdly, not only the final decision but also the process is important. The undertaking should verify whether the SRS has acted within its prescribed deadlines and utilized the procedure stipulated by law.
Therefore, upon receiving a denial for a tax overpayment refund, the undertaking should verify at least three aspects:
- whether the declaration amendment was submitted within the statutory period;
- whether the SRS acted within its prescribed deadline; and
- whether the denial is based on the results of an audit, rather than assumptions about the undertaking’s conduct.
In a tax dispute, an undertaking’s position is determined not only by whether the tax has been calculated correctly. Equally crucial is whether the institution, in making its decision, has observed the statutory process and the taxpayer’s rights.
Need help? Contact us
ALISA LEŠKOVIČA
PARTNER, ATTORNEY AT LAW
Alisa is an experienced attorney and a partner at RockBridge Legal. Since 2008, 2008, Alisa has been advising clients and providing legal assistance in the most complex tax and customs matters.
Alisa also specializes in anti-money laundering (AML), sanctions, and compliance matters. Alisa has significant experience in corporate crime and investigation cases related to tax, customs, and sanctions issues.